Skip to content
Hi, Bot
All Hi, Bot games

› Hi, Bot Games

Cause or Coincidence? Two lines move together. Who's really in charge?

Ice cream sales and lake rescues go up and down together. Does ice cream cause rescues? 12 Cases, each with a chart of two lines that move together. Sort every one with your fingers: A causes B, B causes A, a hidden third thing causes both, or pure luck. Every chart matches in 8 to 10 of 11 steps, so matching proves nothing. The Reveal cards show the tell: who moved first, or what was highest in the same months. It is the statistics under chatbot mistakes, bias and shortcuts.

2–8 players · ~8–14 + teachers · ~20 min · screen-free

Print tonight

Instruction sheet, Case Mat and Case Charts on plain paper, one side, Actual Size / 100%. Cards: Avery 5388 at Actual Size / 100% (never Fit to page). Tear on the perforation.

How to play

Twelve Cases, each a pair of things whose charts move together. Is A making B happen, is it backwards, is a hidden third thing behind both, or is it luck? On 3-2-1, show 1, 2, 3 or 4 fingers. The Reveal card says who was right. +2 for the right pile, and a Sure coin can double it. Highest score wins.

  1. Quick start — read this, start playing

    • Each player takes a Case Mat and 2 Sure coins. Lay both Case Charts pages where the whole table can see them.
    • The Reader flips the top Case card, reads it aloud, and all players find its chart.
    • Count 3-2-1 and show fingers: 1 = A causes B, 2 = B causes A, 3 = hidden third thing, 4 = luck. A Sure coin goes on your mat first.
    • The Reader turns over the Reveal card. +2 if you were right. Sure coin: +4 if right, -1 if wrong. Case card goes in its pile.
    • That is the whole game. Everything below is here for when a question comes up.
  2. Setup

    • Each player or team takes a Case Mat and 2 Sure coins (any coins or tokens). Lay both Case Charts pages in the middle of the table.
    • Match each Case card (C-) with the Reveal card (R-) that has the same number. Put the Case card face-down on top of its Reveal card. That makes 12 stacks. Shuffle the stacks.
    • Whoever sets up should not read the Reveal cards. The youngest player is the first Reader. The Reader plays too.
  3. Each Case

    • The Reader slides the Case card off the top stack and reads its title and story aloud. All players find that chart.
    • Study the two lines and ask the Four Questions on your mat. Decide in secret.
    • Want to use a Sure coin? Put it on your mat now. Then count 3-2-1 and all players show 1, 2, 3 or 4 fingers.
    • The Reader turns over the Reveal card and reads all of it, including the line at the bottom. Check your fingers against it.
    • Put the Case card face-up in the pile for its truth. There are four piles on the table. Pass the Reader role to the left.
  4. Scoring

    • +2 for the right pile.
    • Sure coin: +4 if you were right, -1 if you were wrong. The coin is spent either way, and you only have 2.
    • Perfect score is 28: every Case right, both Sure coins on right calls.
    • Ties: more right calls on HIDDEN THIRD Cases, then the younger player.
  5. Tips

    • Every chart moves together in 8 to 10 of 11 steps, so "they move together" tells you nothing. Ask who moved FIRST.
    • If B repeats A's moves a step later, A might cause B. If A repeats B, it runs backwards. If neither leads, look for a hidden third thing or call luck.
    • HIDDEN THIRD is the biggest pile (5 of 12 Cases). Calling it every time scores only 10. You need the other piles to get near 28.
    • Spend a Sure coin when you can name the hidden thing, or point at who moved first.
  6. What the cards teach

    • Correlation - two things whose charts move together. The link can be real, backwards, shared, or luck.
    • Cause - one thing makes the other happen, and it moves first.
    • Hidden third thing - something behind both that nobody put on the chart. Scientists call it a confounder.
    • Luck - short charts line up by chance all the time. Twelve points is not much evidence.
    • AI link - a bot learns patterns from its data. If the data hides the real cause, the bot learns the shortcut, and fails when the world changes.
  7. Variants

    • Younger players - take out the Backwards Cases (C-05, C-09) and play 10. Perfect is 20 without Sure coins.
    • Solo - flip all 12 Cases yourself, write your finger count on paper, then reveal. 9 or more right is a Statistician.
    • Teams - a team gets 15 seconds to huddle, then shows one number.
    • Classroom - project the Charts. After each Reveal one student finishes: "The hidden thing could be ___ because ___."
    • Fix it - for any HIDDEN THIRD Case, say what you would measure to prove it, like comparing only the hot months.
    • Make your own - pick two things from your life, draw both lines, and ask the table to sort it.

Downloads

  • Instruction sheet

    Plain paper · 1 page · 8.5 × 11

    One 8.5 × 11 page for the table — quick start, setup, turns, and scoring.

  • Full rules

    Plain paper · duplex · 2 pages

    Same game, longer type — plus what the cards teach and the variants.

  • Case Mat

    Plain paper · 1 page · 8.5 × 11

    The four piles with their finger counts, the four questions, two Sure coins and a score row. One per player or team.

  • Case Charts

    Plain paper · 2 pages · 8.5 × 11

    12 charts, each two lines over 12 months or weeks. One set per table.

  • Case + Reveal cards (Avery 5388)

    Avery 5388 · 8 sheets

    12 Case cards (the story and the chart number) and 12 Reveal cards (what was really going on).

  • Grown-up guide

    Plain paper · 1 page · 8.5 × 11

    One page for teachers and parents: why matching charts prove less than they seem to, how to run it with a class, and talk-about-it questions.

Rules preview

Same rules as above, laid out for the table. Keep a printed copy face-up while you score.

On a phone, open the PDF in a new tab — in-page previews are unreliable in mobile Safari.

Played Cause or Coincidence??

Playtest notes — round length, rule confusion, print quality, teach-back moments — help us tune the game.

Send playtest feedback →

Want more than card games?

Want facilitator-ready printables the day they drop, plus the full Activities library for grades 6–12? Activities Pass — 14 days free, then $5/month or $39/year. Browser games like this one stay free either way.

Start 14-day free trial →

Homeschooling? Print tips & FAQ · Want the screen-free activity library? Free printables · Start 14-day free trial